Welcome to another episode of Invest & Scale! In this conversation, Gabriel Murillo sits down with Miller Hilliard of Surety Bond Solutions, a Baton Rouge surety agency serving construction companies across the Gulf South. Miller wasn’t looking for a deal. The deal found him — through a weekly lunch table of business owners he had been joining with his grandfather since he was a teenager.
Miller explains why he walked away from a clear path to owning a State Farm agency, and he breaks down the owner-financed earn-out he agreed on with the seller: come on board as an employee, double the company in five years, then acquire it with no debt hanging overhead. He also talks candidly about two years of cold outreach that went nowhere, the COVID-era pivot that finally broke it open, and how he rewrote his own job description once the business no longer needed him in the weeds.
If you’re an acquisition entrepreneur interested in creative deal structures, seller relationships, or growing a business through reputation instead of price, this one is full of practical ground to cover.
00:55 Growing up around business owners
03:23 Choosing the State Farm path
04:19 Running an agency six months out of college
05:58 The deal finds Miller
06:49 Why retention changed everything
11:00 Luck and being in the right rooms
11:57 The seller’s heart in the deal
15:46 Double the company in five years
17:50 Leaving State Farm
19:29 Telling the team from day one
21:45 Mentors, doubters, and advisors
26:17 Imposter syndrome and constant learning
29:34 COVID and changing the sales approach
35:07 Redefining the owner’s role
39:01 Industry groups and peer networks
41:01 Lessons for the next acquisition
44:35 Final advice for acquisition entrepreneurs
1. Early Exposure to Ownership
– Starting at 15 or 16, Miller joined his grandfather’s standing lunch with a group of business owners, most of them decades older. He also sold RVs through college and picked up sales, finance, and how to hold a conversation with an owner.
2. The State Farm Route
– He worked for a State Farm agent through his last two years at LSU and entered the agent-training program. When the owner’s daughter died unexpectedly, Miller ran the agency for about a year with little experience and no formal authority over the team.
3. An Unexpected Opportunity
– His grandfather mentioned Miller’s State Farm plans at lunch. The next day, one of the men at that table called asking for Miller’s number — he wanted Miller to buy his company.
4. Why Surety Stood Out
– The State Farm agency lost roughly 10% of its book every year to rate shopping and life changes. Randy’s agency had lost two or three clients in a decade, because surety runs on relationships rather than price.
5. The Seller’s Heart in the Deal
– Randy had sold once before and bought the company back when the buyer failed to take care of his clients and employees. The second time around, protecting those two groups mattered more to him than the size of the check.
6. An Earn-Out Structure
– Miller joined as an employee with five years to double the company. If he hit it, Randy would owner-finance 100% of the sale through an earn-out tied to the book of business, with terms agreed upfront. Miller avoided a large debt load, and Randy expects to earn more than a standard multiple would have paid him.
7. Transparency With the Team
– Employees knew from Miller’s first day that he was expected to buy the company. Randy framed it as the way to keep their jobs secure long term, brought Miller into decisions early, and still serves on the leadership team today.
8. Mentors and Advisors
– Some people told him the structure was too good to be true. Miller leaned on mentors, his banker, his CPA, and an attorney, guided by a principle he still repeats: the paperwork should simply say what both parties already agreed to.
9. Two Hard Years and a Pivot
– Door-knocking large contractors produced the same answer every time — “I’ve had my guy for 40 years.” During COVID he flipped the approach and went after brand-new small contractors instead. Those relationships compounded slowly, then took off, and the company doubled in about two and a half years.
10. Redefining the Owner’s Role
– After the acquisition, a new salesperson, a vice president, outsourced accounting, and AI automations freed Miller up. He wrote himself a new job description built around being the magnet that draws people toward the business.
11. Building Through Networks
– Miller is active in industry groups including AGC and the Louisiana Surety Association, plus EO, Alpha Strategic Partners, and Bros with Goals. He almost never asks for business, focusing instead on being useful until people wonder why they aren’t already working with him.
12. Looking Ahead
– His next targets are competitors in the same industry, starting locally. High multiples make creative offers essential, so he plans to build each one around what matters most to that particular seller.
13. Final Advice
– Miller borrows a line from Alex Hormozi: fear is a mile wide and an inch deep. Take the leap, lean on advisors, listen to opinions, and don’t ignore your gut.
Resources: